Publication Ethics & Malpractice Statement

JOURNAL POLICIES
 

Biology and Education Journal (BaEJ) · UIR Press

1. Authorship and Contributorship

Authorship in Biology and Education Journal (BaEJ) should reflect substantial intellectual contributions to the research and manuscript. Authors are expected to meet the following criteria:

  1. Make substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work, data acquisition, or data analysis and interpretation.
  2. Draft the manuscript or critically revise it for important intellectual content.
  3. Approve the final version for publication.
  4. Agree to be accountable for the integrity and accuracy of the work and to address questions concerning any part of it.

All individuals who meet the authorship criteria should be listed as authors. Contributors who do not meet these criteria should be acknowledged appropriately. The corresponding author is responsible for submitting accurate information about each author's contribution and confirming that all co-authors have approved the manuscript and its submission.

Contributor Roles

BaEJ encourages authors to describe individual contributions using the following roles, where applicable:

  • Conceptualization: Development of research ideas, objectives, and aims.
  • Data Curation: Organization, annotation, cleaning, and maintenance of research data.
  • Formal Analysis: Application of statistical, mathematical, computational, or other analytical methods.
  • Funding Acquisition: Obtaining financial support for the research.
  • Investigation: Conducting experiments, research activities, and data collection.
  • Methodology: Development or design of research methods and models.
  • Project Administration: Coordination and management of research activities.
  • Supervision: Research oversight, leadership, and mentorship.
  • Validation: Verification of results, methods, and reproducibility.
  • Visualization: Preparation of figures, charts, and data presentations.
  • Writing – Original Draft: Preparation of the initial manuscript.
  • Writing – Review and Editing: Critical review, revision, and editing of the manuscript.

Reference: COPE: Authorship and Contributorship.

2. Complaints and Appeals

BaEJ handles complaints and appeals fairly, transparently, and confidentially, following applicable publication ethics principles. Authors who disagree with an editorial decision may submit a reasoned appeal to the editorial office.

Appeals should include:
  • A clear explanation of the grounds for disagreeing with the decision.
  • Specific responses to relevant editorial and reviewer comments.
  • New information or evidence that may affect the assessment.
  • Evidence of possible technical errors or an undisclosed reviewer conflict of interest, where relevant.

Complaints about editorial conduct, peer review, or possible breaches of publication ethics should be directed to the editorial office with supporting details. The journal will assess each case and determine appropriate action. Appeals do not guarantee that a decision will be reversed.

Reference: COPE: Appeals and Complaints.

3. Conflicts of Interest

A conflict of interest, also known as a competing interest, exists when financial, personal, professional, institutional, or other relationships could influence, or reasonably appear to influence, the objectivity of research or editorial decisions.

Authors must disclose relevant competing interests when submitting a manuscript. Editors and reviewers must also disclose potential conflicts and withdraw from the assessment when impartiality cannot reasonably be ensured. The editorial team will evaluate disclosed conflicts and determine whether further action or disclosure to readers is necessary.

4. Data Sharing and Reproducibility

BaEJ encourages authors to promote transparency and reproducibility by making the data, analytical code, research instruments, and other supporting materials underlying their findings available when appropriate.

Authors are encouraged to deposit research data in a suitable repository, cite relevant datasets in the reference list, and include a data availability statement. Data sharing must comply with applicable ethical requirements, participant consent, confidentiality obligations, intellectual property rights, and data protection regulations.

When data cannot be made publicly available because of privacy, confidentiality, security, legal, or ethical restrictions, authors should explain the restriction in their data availability statement. Editors may request additional information when necessary to assess the integrity of the research.
5. Research Ethics and Ethical Oversight

BaEJ is committed to research integrity, honesty, transparency, responsible conduct, and respect for research participants. Authors are responsible for ensuring that their studies comply with applicable institutional, national, and international ethical requirements.

  • Human participants: Research involving human participants must comply with applicable ethical standards. Authors should provide ethics committee approval details and informed consent information where required.
  • Animal research: Studies involving animals must follow relevant animal welfare requirements and applicable institutional and national regulations.
  • Funding: Authors must disclose relevant funding sources and grant support.
  • Hazardous materials and procedures: Research involving potentially hazardous materials or procedures must follow relevant safety and ethical requirements.
  • Research integrity: Authors must not engage in fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, inappropriate image manipulation, or other forms of research misconduct.

The journal may request supporting documentation when needed to assess ethical compliance. Any concerns will be handled in accordance with relevant journal policies and publication ethics procedures.

6. Advertising Policy

Any advertising displayed on the BaEJ website must not influence editorial decisions, peer review, acceptance, or publication outcomes. Advertising, if used, should be clearly distinguishable from editorial content and managed independently of the editorial decision-making process.

7. Intellectual Property and Copyright

Authors are responsible for ensuring that submitted manuscripts and supporting materials do not infringe the rights of others. Authors must obtain permission to reproduce copyrighted tables, figures, images, text, or other material whenever required.

Authors retain copyright in their work according to the journal's stated copyright policy. Manuscripts, reviewer reports, and editorial correspondence must be handled confidentially. The use and distribution of published articles are governed by the journal's separate copyright and licensing policies.

8. Post-Publication Discussions and Corrections

BaEJ recognizes the importance of post-publication discussion in maintaining the accuracy and integrity of the scholarly record. The journal may consider substantive comments, concerns, and scholarly responses relating to published articles, subject to editorial assessment and applicable review procedures.

Possible Editorial Actions
  • Correction: A corrigendum or erratum may be published to correct an error that does not invalidate the article's main findings.
  • Editor's Note: A notice may inform readers that a concern is being assessed.
  • Expression of Concern: A formal notice may be issued when significant concerns exist and an investigation remains unresolved.
  • Retraction: An article may be retracted when findings are unreliable or serious ethical misconduct is established.

Authors will be given an appropriate opportunity to respond to concerns. Where necessary, the journal may consult independent experts or relevant institutions. Editorial notices will be linked to the affected article to preserve transparency and the scholarly record.

Reference: COPE: Post-Publication Discussions and Corrections.

9. Reporting Ethical Concerns

Authors, reviewers, editors, and readers may report suspected breaches of publication ethics, authorship disputes, plagiarism, data manipulation, conflicts of interest, or concerns about published articles to the BaEJ editorial office. Reports should include a clear description of the concern and relevant supporting information.

BaEJ will assess reports fairly and confidentially and determine appropriate next steps in accordance with its publication ethics policies. The journal may seek independent advice or contact relevant institutions when necessary.

Please submit complaints and ethical concerns through the journal's official editorial office or OJS discussion system. Use the contact details published on the journal website.

Biology and Education Journal (BaEJ)
Published by UIR Press · Universitas Islam Riau